"There is nothing more important than learning to think- except learning to teach someone to think"
Nanci Bell
So I just wanted to take some time and tell you all about my
little wonderful elementary school in Mboula, that I have been working so
closely with this past year. As my service is rapidly coming to a close, I have
been reflecting a lot on the work (or attempted work) I have done these past
two years. For me, the most rewarding work I have done is with the students and
teachers at L’Ecole Elementaire El Hadji Abdoulaye Mbengue. From educational
nutritional talks to planting sunflowers, my collaboration with the teachers and
students of Mboula has been memorable to say the least.
I can still remember
the first time I visited the school. It was around 11 am; the teachers were
sitting around each other in a circle drinking tea, the children were running
around the school, wrestling and dancing like they were high on sugar. As soon
as the kids saw me, they rushed at me screaming “Toubab”. I had about 60-70
kids all around me, touching, staring and grabbing at me until one of the
teachers came screaming and chased them off with a stick. I thought to myself
“Oh god what have I got myself into.” A lot has changed since then. I now can
understand what the teachers are saying to me and often join in on their tea
breaks at 11am. The kids call me “Fatou” rather than “Toubab” and I have gained
many little friends. I have been very fortunate to have very friendly,
motivated and enthusiastic teachers who have always supported me and my work. I
have also come to love the majority of students in Mboula (there still are some
that drive me bonkers) and appreciate them for embracing me as I am, even if I
am a strange “Toubab”.
L’Ecole Elementaire El Hadji Abdoulaye Mbengue is what they
call a Franco/Arabic school. The students learn all their subjects in French
and Arabic. A normal school day starts at 8am and the teachers will have a
strict lesson plan lined up for the students with an objective they must obtain.
Straying from the lesson plans is not tolerated. There is no room for outside
of the box ways for presenting a lesson plan. Creativity is very limited. At 11am, the students get a little 30-minute
break to run home and grab some food to eat. A lot of women in the village will
come and sell the children beignets, fatayas, roasted peanuts and cold bissap
juice. After the break, the students will switch to either learning their
lessons in French or Arabic. I think it is so impressive that these students
learn different languages at such a young age. I really wish I had that when I
was in elementary school. School is
normally over at 1:30, right in time for the kids to make it home for lunch. On
Tuesdays and Thursdays, the students have afternoon class from 4-6pm and
normally are fed lunch at the school.
There is a total of 6 classrooms at the school in Mboula. It
is just like elementary school in America- kindergarten to fifth grade. There
is a classroom for each grade level. However, the classrooms look like they are
crumbling apart; there are no fans (and during hot season the classrooms are
unbearable), and the desks are wooden benches ( I have no clue how the children
sit in those seats for hours). Here teachers do the best they can with what
they have and a lot of times that means
overcrowded classrooms, not enough qualified teachers, teacher strikes because
they haven’t been paid, worn out school books that are outdated, and not enough
utensils for the students to use. And yet students and teachers both show up
each day ready to learn and teach.
The students here are taught in a very formatted way. A
teacher will write the lesson on the board and the students are expected to
copy word for word what was written. Students will then go home and spend hours
memorizing what they wrote down in their notebooks. It seems like such an
outdated and backwards way of learning, but unfortunately teachers and students
are not aware of the different ways in which people learn. Students here must
conform to the ways the teacher teaches, which is just memorizing lesson plan after lesson plan.
Some students are great at memorizing, while others struggle to learn with that
method, in which case they are kind of shit out of luck and left behind. It is
hard to imagine how any child learns in
this kind of environment where teachers are not attuned to their students’ needs. If there is a child who
is struggling with assignments, there is no one to reach out and help. There is
no alone-time with a teacher to help a student better understand a lesson plan.
The students who are most in need of a little extra attention are often times
the ones who are cast off to the side.
Students are not taught to think for themselves but instead
are taught right or wrong. This is the way something is and nothing else. It is
a system of yes and no answers. There is no room for debate or to ask questions
of why. I have rarely ever seen a child raise their hand and ask a teacher “but
why”. In fact, most students in class don’t raise their hands at all to ask
questions for fear of being ridiculed by classmates (being called stupid for
not understanding). However they will always (and are very much expected) to raise their hands when a teacher asks them a
question, even if they do not know the answer; which unfortunately sometimes
can result in that child getting his/her hand slapped with a strip of rubber
multiple times.
Yes, corporal punishment is allowed here and boy do they use
it. Each time I am at the school I see numerous children getting hit for
various reasons: talking, not answering the question and even getting the
answer incorrect. There was this one
occasion where Fae and I were painting the map of Africa in one of the
classrooms during an Arabic class. For some reason that I do not know of, the
teacher in the classroom (who is generally a really nice and great guy) took
his strip of rubber and started to hit these two girls hands really, really
hard multiple times to the point that both girls started to hysterically cry. He
then made them stand in front of the classroom, in front of their peers until
they stopped crying. It just seemed so unnecessary and cruel.
I do not believe in corporal punishment and it kills me
sometimes to see the teachers hit their students, but unfortunately that is how
teachers here gain discipline and respect. It very much is an environment that
feeds off negativity, but then again that is really how Senegalese culture is.
There are no encouraging words or positive reinforcement from teachers or
parents. Students don’t have someone cheering them on in their corner saying
“Well done” or “Good try”. However, people
here have no problem pointing out your flaws. Parents or teachers are quick to
call out if a student is “stupid” or (as they like to phrase it) “has no
usefulness.” It is phrases like these that students hear on a daily basis. A
student who is not making the grades and passing on to the next grade level
will not get any extra encouragement or help, but instead will most likely be
pulled out of school by his/her parents and put to work in the fields or some
other technical work. Why would parents spend money on a child who is
apparently not smart enough to go to school? Obviously it was not God’s will
for that child to learn. They have no one to believe in them but themselves. I
think it is commendable that under such conditions, children even show up to
school. Even though the teachers in the school are great and positive people,
they don’t encourage their students the way that teachers in the U.S. do; and I
think that that makes a big difference.
I remember when I was in school, all of my classrooms were
decorated in brightly colored arts and crafts projects and pretty educational
visual aids that lined the classroom walls. There was always an endless supply
of pencils, pens, glue, erasers, crayons, markers, paper, scissors and staples.
Teachers always had fun interactive lesson plans and all the resources needed
for those plans. I can remember having a
world culture day at school in which my Mom cooked her Indian Curry for all the
children to try just so they could get a taste of a different culture. In
second grade, my teacher Mrs. Sivennen, had us read about seven different
versions of the Cinderella story from all over the world, and then she
recreated our classroom into Cinderella’s Ball. All of the girls brought their
dads as dates and all the boys brought their mothers. I can still remember
waltzing with my Dad in one of my flower girl dresses and feeling like a
princess that day!
We had it all in school- the books, the supplies, the fancy
classrooms, the qualified and inspiring teachers, not to mention all the
afterschool programs . There were so many afterschool clubs and teams that you
could participate in. I remember being on the basketball team, track team,
Spanish club, chorus and video production. I even participated in one of the
school plays. I was a singing flower in the background. Everything imaginable
was at the tips of our fingers. Education was so available for us. With that
being said, and with the time that I have spent working with this elementary
school in Mboula, I can’t help but feel like I took my education for granted. I think
of all the wonderful opportunities I had right at my fingertips and I don’t
think I ever truly appreciated them until now. I still remember all the
countless mornings my parents had to force me to get up and go to school. All
the wasted temper-tantrums and fake sick attempts I tried, just to get out of
going to school all seems so ridiculous and pointless now. Having seen how few
opportunities there are for children in Senegal, it seems silly for children in
America to go to such lengths just to get out of all the amazing opportunities
that are provided for them at school.
At the elementary school in Mboula, there are no classroom
decorations or pretty educational visual aids hung around the classroom walls. The
classrooms don’t have an endless supply of pencils, pens, markers, glue,
crayons or glue. There are no art classes for kids to participate in or school
plays, or after school clubs or sports teams for them. Besides, the only sports
team they can really participate in anyways is soccer; it would be pretty hard
for them to play basketball in the sand. I think the most interactive and fun
the students have had is when Fae and I organized a school relay day in which
we set up relay races for the kids to participate in. And yet everyone is
content. Teachers and students are grateful and appreciative of what little
they do have. My teachers have never asked anything of me. They have had plenty
of opportunities to ask for things like “Fatou, give us some supplies,” or
“Fatou, build us new classrooms.” But I
think that is one of the main reasons I have really been motivated and enjoyed
working with them -because they don’t expect anything.
Some of the work I have done with the school in Photos
School Correspondance The kids wrote letters in french to my old highschool, South Fork back in Florida, talking about their lives in Senegal. They also received letters from students back home (Thanks a geat deal to Mrs.Ralicki for helping to make it happen)
Sun Flower planting at the school.
Educational Maps in each of the 6 classrooms
Educational discussions: Handwashing/ Diarrhea and Nutrition
My Wonderful School: L'Ecole Elemenataire El Hadji Abdoulaye Mbengue
and it's amazing teachers...
Great commentary, Jennifer. We have so much that we do not appreciate. I am sure your "Fatou" will be remembered in Mboula just as Mrs Sivenen is remembered in Port Salerno.
ReplyDelete